Guthwulf Posted August 17, 2007 Author Posted August 17, 2007 not until the 21st, thats when the competition ends Quote
cntrstrk14 Posted August 17, 2007 Posted August 17, 2007 Got bored. EDIT: Made a slight change. Quote
Arashi Posted August 17, 2007 Posted August 17, 2007 Also, please be a little more professional, telling WHY you voted for one or another... (grades is also a good system in this kind of competition...) Quote
ViperRKB Posted August 21, 2007 Posted August 21, 2007 ~The Scores~ Cntr- 9/10- The blood spatter effect made the sig. The colors worked together nicely, and its crystal clear. The clock was kind of... Random -points for that. Chiri-o 8/10- Nice background and style. The color is good, but it is really too simple. A few more effects would have made it perfect. Se7en 8/10- Really nice sig, and at first glance it looks like a winner, at closer inspection though the color is really jumbled up in there and very hard to see. Plus it strains my eyes to see so many bright colors with relatively little shading. Everything left of the [vertical text]love[/vertical text] is good though. Kassiel 2/10- I can make out... Vetemination. Thats about it. Pretty cool twisty yellow thing though +2 for that. Way to blurry and way too much color jumble. Arashi 7/10- It's very blurry, but it kinda fits with the style. The background is pretty cool, but I still would go without the blurry... Maybe if you made the layer with the blur effect on it a Lighten layer it would look cooler. (I actually wouldn't mind seeing that) Takius 7/10- Love the background, was not too fond of the focus of the body. At the same time it's kinda original to focus on the torso. It was killed by the effect on the body of the changing lightness and darkness. Kinda made me dizzy. Quote
Kassiel Posted August 21, 2007 Posted August 21, 2007 (edited) Well, i kinda figured i'd be last...buuut, w/ever, grats to all who beat me. (Not really all that great an achievement. Edited August 21, 2007 by Kassiel Quote
ViperRKB Posted August 21, 2007 Posted August 21, 2007 There are still the other voters, don't rush to a conclusion yet. Quote
Temperence Posted August 21, 2007 Posted August 21, 2007 Lulz Ok here goes the scoring..... Cntr- 8.5/10 I liked this sig alot the blood spatter was pretty cool and the background was quite decent. But there was mroe you porbably could have done with it. Chir- 7/10 Your sig was pretty cool with all the arrows and such, but a plain green background except for the black shading around the render was kinda dull :x. Se7en- 9/10 I really liekd this sig alot, its a very cool looking style in my opinion and judging by the look of it it porbably took alot of work, the different colors and coloring of the render really make it stand out. Awesome job. Kassiel- 2/10 This sig was very hard ot red and very hard to understand what was going on. I really didnt get the whole idea behind this sig. Therefore 2/10. Arashi- 8/10 Your sig looked pretty cool to me, i love the things you did with the render and everything else in the render, overall great job with this sig. Takius 8/10 Another great sig, love your style tak, the hwole not showing the focus of the render and making it another point is very cool. Loved what you did with the background and such, thus the 8 out of 10, gratz. Quote
Kassiel Posted August 21, 2007 Posted August 21, 2007 Hey, i know it's too late, but i wanted to know what you thought of try number 2: Quote
ViperRKB Posted August 21, 2007 Posted August 21, 2007 Doesn't count, but I give it a 7. Pretty cool, just lacks something to focus on at the left side Quote
Kassiel Posted August 21, 2007 Posted August 21, 2007 ok, made some changes to it, and this is what i came up with, Try #3: Quote
ViperRKB Posted August 21, 2007 Posted August 21, 2007 (edited) Make it a Hidden Leaf symbol and you got yourself a sig. Also less transparent. Alot less. Edited August 21, 2007 by ViperRKB Quote
Guthwulf Posted August 22, 2007 Author Posted August 22, 2007 (edited) The Judges shall now cast their votes. Judges, you know who you are, please rate each sig on a scale from 1 to 10 and send them to me in a PM, then, whoever gets the highest score will be the winner. The next highest score will be 2nd place. If there is a tie for first the two sigs that got first will be voted no by the forum goers. Good Luck the scores are as follows, but these are not the final scores for I am still waiting on pwnzie Viper's Scores Cntr- 9/10- Chiri-o 8/10- Se7en 8/10- Kassiel 2/10- Arashi 7/10- Takius 7/10- Guthwulf's Scores Takius 8/10 Arashi 9/10 Seven 9/10 Chiri-o 6/10 Cntr 8/10 Kassiel 3/10 Pwnzie's Scores Cntr- 8.5/10 Chir- 7/10 Se7en- 9/10 Kassiel- 2/10 Arashi- 8/10 Takius 8/10 Total Scores Cntr 25.5 Chiri-o 21 Seven 26 Kassiel 7 Arashi 24 Takius 23 By a vote of 25.5 to 26.... SEVEN WINS! Second Place goes to, Cntr great job on all of your sigs, it was a very tough desicion on the scores, in the end someone one by only half a score! again great job all, there will be another next week. Edited August 22, 2007 by Guthwulf Quote
